In French Labor Overhaul, Union Leader Offers a Way to a Compromise

In French Labor Overhaul, Union Leader Offers a Way to a Compromise

- in Business
7
0

“We’ve just had a profound political shift, so we’re at a turning point where things can really change,” Mr. Berger said in an interview.

Much is at stake. Unemployment has been stuck around 10 percent for four years, and the economy has failed to recover from the financial crisis as fast as Germany’s.

Mr. Macron wants to steer France toward a more Scandinavian-style economic model known as “flexible security.” Pioneered in Denmark, it promotes consensus between unions and employers, and it aims to minimize joblessness by making it easy for companies to adjust their work force and by retraining the unemployed.

The idea is to no longer protect jobs for life, while giving people skills to transition to different careers.

“Workers still need protection, but in a globalized world, the economy must be able to adjust, too,” Mr. Berger said. “If unions just oppose everything, we’ll never move forward.”

A labor union protest at Place de la République in Paris in June 2016.

Credit
Peter Kneffel/European Pressphoto Agency

Whether Mr. Berger follows words with actions remains to be seen. The C.F.D.T., as the union is known, recently became France’s largest when its membership surpassed the militant General Confederation of Labor, which has dominated the landscape for decades.

Amid Mr. Macron’s rise, Mr. Berger has sometimes painted his union as a moderating influence in France’s labor movement at a crucial moment for the economy. Mr. Berger has pushed for a more flexible approach in France as the forces of globalization change the competitive landscape.

Yet he is not immune to protesting when the stakes are high. On Sunday, he urged Mr. Macron to maintain discussions with unions and employer groups — or risk new demonstrations.

In France, even small changes tend to rile labor organizations, which have historically sought to secure workplace protections through protests and strikes. The General Confederation of Labor, known as the C.G.T., has been at the forefront of mobilizing frequent, sometimes violent actions, whether burning tires or even holding bosses captive.

And while unions are at their weakest membership levels ever — representing just 8 percent of the work force — they can still thwart big changes to totems like the length of the workweek, or measures that would undermine their own power.

Mr. Macron’s plans contain several elements that unions, including the C.F.D.T., see as red lines. Foremost is a proposal to allow employers to negotiate directly with employees on a range of workplace issues, overriding sector-wide accords struck by unions. Labor organizations also oppose a measure to cap compensation awards in unfair dismissal cases.

Mr. Berger insists his union is not the government’s foe. An imposing, energetic man from a working-class family in northern France, he became a labor activist after an early career helping disadvantaged and poor people.

He is willing to give employers more flexibility to downsize when the economy sours, provided that they hire when conditions improve and that those who lost jobs are protected and retrained.

In France, “there’s a natural conflict between employers and employees,” he said at the C.F.D.T. headquarters, where sun streamed through gleaming windows replacing the ones that had been smashed. “But does it take a battle or dialogue to build compromise? I choose dialogue.”

His position has engendered detractors, who see the C.F.D.T. as selling out to business interests. The protesters who vandalized his offices denounced him as a traitor. Others wielded signs proclaiming, “When slavery is re-established, the C.F.D.T. will negotiate the length of the chains!”

President Emmanuel Macron, left, met with Mr. Berger at the Élysée Palace in Paris last month.

Credit
Pool photo by Michel Euler

Yet it would seem to be a strategic move in the era of Mr. Macron, a centrist whose swift rise has upended France’s traditional power balance. His République en Marche party’s majority in the National Assembly will give him momentum to push a strongly pro-business agenda.

Divisions within France’s labor movement may play to Mr. Macron’s advantage. The C.G.T., which traces its roots to the French Communist party, has never been overtaken by another union. It may face challenges if Mr. Berger’s union sets a more moderate tone for trade-offs.

Philippe Martinez, the C.G.T.’s leader, has said his organization does not necessarily oppose changes to the labor code. But last week, he maintained threats of mass protests if employee protections are cut too much.

Just weeks into his presidency, Mr. Macron has already summoned labor leaders — starting with Mr. Berger — for marathon sessions to discuss overhaul plans, which will be fast-tracked through executive orders in summer. Mr. Macron has scheduled 50 more meetings with the unions through July, and more rounds in August and September.

“Macron is good at talking to the unions, at giving them something,” said Philippe Aghion, an economics professor at Harvard and at the prestigious Collège de France who mentored Mr. Macron as a student, and who advises him on labor policy. “He’ll take what they say into account.”

Still, Mr. Macron’s political wins mask weaknesses that are not lost on union leaders. His parliamentary victory was overshadowed by record-low voter turnout. And many who backed Mr. Macron for president did so to keep his rival, the far-right National Front leader Marine Le Pen, from winning — not to see him weaken labor protections.

“Right now, people are saying, ‘He’s just been elected president, let’s give him a chance,’” Jean-Claude Mailly, the leader of Force Ouvrière, the third-largest union, said at a recent news briefing. “But there’s real anger in France.”

In the current discontent, Mr. Berger is similarly walking a fine line between playing a leadership role during the president’s overhaul drive, and placating members of his own union wary of radical change. Still, Mr. Berger insists he is not aiming to incite mass protests just yet.

“There’s a mentality in France that says we should cut off the heads of those at the top,” he said. “And there’s also a French tendency to focus on things that could go wrong.”

He paused, then continued in a firm voice. “We can change that,” he said.

“I have no desire to be among those who keep saying, ‘None of this will work.’ It has to work,” Mr. Berger added. “Because if it doesn’t, we’ll wind up with Le Pen in another five years. And things will be much, much worse.”

Continue reading the main story

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like

Part of Hudson Yards Tunnels Is Nearly Done. Now It Sits, Unused.

The building of the river tunnel hasn’t begun